BestBuyr

BestBuyr

How we review

How we choose products, what our ratings mean, and what they are not based on.

Last updated

Every BestBuyr guide follows the same method, so you know what our picks and ratings are based on, and what they are not based on.

1. Start from the buyer

A guide begins with a buying situation, not a product category: a small kitchen, a long commute, a windy beach, a shared home office. We write down who is buying, what they need the product to do and what usually disappoints people in that situation. That decides what we compare.

2. Build a shortlist

We look at the products that are actually on sale in the guide’s market (United States, United Kingdom, India, Germany or France) and narrow them to a shortlist, usually five to ten products. Products that are discontinued, hard to buy in that market, or clearly outclassed at the same kind of price do not make the list. Some guides end with a short section on what we ruled out and why.

3. Check the facts

For each product we compare specifications, sizes, power, compatibility, warranty terms and availability using the manufacturer’s own documentation where it exists, retailer listings, and public feedback from owners. Where sources disagree, we go with the manufacturer’s documentation and say when something could not be confirmed.

Unless a guide says otherwise, we have not tested the products hands-on. We do not invent measurements, test results or personal experiences.

4. Score and choose

Most guides include a comparison scorecard that rates each product out of 10 on criteria such as value, core performance, build, ease of use, features and fit for the buyer. These are our editorial judgements based on the research above. The “Our rating” shown on a pick is our overall assessment for the buyer the guide is written for.

Our ratings are not retailer star ratings and are not averages of customer reviews. We do not copy star ratings or review counts from Amazon or any other retailer.

We then name a pick for each kind of buyer, such as best overall, best value or best for a specific need, rather than a single winner for everyone, and we state each pick’s trade-offs.

5. Prices

We do not publish prices. Retail prices change constantly and differ between stores, so any price we printed would soon be wrong. Where it helps, a guide may describe a product as budget, mid-range or premium. Always check the current price on the retailer’s site before you buy.

6. How AI is used

Guides are drafted with the help of AI writing tools, working from the research described above. Before a guide is published it is checked against our editorial and compliance rules: affiliate disclosure, correct store links for the guide’s market, no copied prices, ratings or retailer images, and no unsupported claims. When we find a problem after publishing, we fix it and update the guide.

7. Updates

We revisit guides when products are replaced, discontinued or change significantly, and when readers report problems. The date at the top of a guide shows when it was last updated.

8. Independence

We earn commissions when readers buy through some of our links (see our affiliate disclosure). Commission rates do not influence our picks, brands cannot pay for inclusion or placement, and we do not accept free products in exchange for coverage.

Questions about a guide, or spotted an error? Email contact@bestbuyr.com.